Q 20. "पूर्व और पश्चिम के बीच नाजुक असंतुलन यू० एस० ए० बनाम रूस-चीनी गठबंधन के बीच उलझन के कारण संयुक्त राष्ट्र में सुधार प्रक्रिया अभी भी अनसुलझी है।" इस संबंध में पूर्व-पश्चिम नीति टकरावों की जाँच और आलोचनात्मक मूल्यांकन कीजिए। (UPSC 2025,15 Marks,250 Words)

EN ह

The United Nations reform process remains unresolved due to the delicate East-West imbalance and the entanglement of the USA against the Russo-Chinese alliance. Scholars like Richard Gowan argue that geopolitical tensions hinder consensus, while Joseph Nye highlights the power dynamics at play. The East-West policy confrontations reflect a struggle for influence, with the USA advocating for democratic values and Russia-China prioritizing sovereignty and non-interference, complicating reform efforts.

East-West Policy Confrontations in UN Reform
  ● Historical Context:  
        ○ The Cold War era established a significant divide between the Eastern bloc led by the Soviet Union and the Western bloc led by the United States. This historical context continues to influence current UN reform debates.
        ○ The UN Security Council (UNSC), with its permanent members (P5), reflects this historical power structure, with Russia and China often aligning against the US, UK, and France.
  ● Power Dynamics:  
        ○ The US and its allies advocate for reforms that promote democracy and human rights, often clashing with Russia and China, who emphasize sovereignty and non-interference.
        ○ The Russo-Chinese alliance often counters Western initiatives, using their veto power to block resolutions perceived as threatening their interests or allies.
  ● Security Council Reform:  
        ○ Proposals for expanding the UNSC to include more permanent members face opposition due to the delicate balance of power. For instance, the G4 nations (Germany, Japan, India, and Brazil) seek permanent seats, but face resistance from current P5 members.
    ● China opposes Japan's bid, while Russia and China are wary of India's inclusion due to regional power dynamics.  
  ● Human Rights and Intervention:  
        ○ The Responsibility to Protect (R2P) doctrine, supported by Western nations, is often resisted by Russia and China, who view it as a pretext for regime change.
        ○ Examples include the Syrian conflict, where Russia and China vetoed resolutions aimed at sanctioning the Assad regime, citing concerns over sovereignty and stability.
  ● Economic and Developmental Policies:  
        ○ The West often pushes for reforms that integrate market economies and liberalization, while the East emphasizes state sovereignty and developmental aid without political conditions.
        ○ The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) by China is seen as a counter to Western economic influence, promoting infrastructure development in exchange for political alliances.
  ● Climate Change and Environmental Policies:  
        ○ The US and EU advocate for stringent climate policies, while Russia and China prioritize economic growth and energy security, often leading to disagreements in international climate negotiations.
        ○ The Paris Agreement saw significant East-West negotiations, with China eventually committing to carbon neutrality by 2060, showcasing a complex interplay of cooperation and competition.
  ● Technological and Cybersecurity Issues:  
        ○ The US and its allies push for regulations on cybersecurity and technology transfer, often clashing with China and Russia, who are accused of cyber espionage and intellectual property theft.
        ○ The debate over 5G technology and Huawei exemplifies these tensions, with the West concerned about security risks and the East focusing on technological advancement.

The UN reform process remains stalled due to the East-West policy confrontations and the USA vs. Russo-Chinese alliance. The Security Council's structure, favoring post-WWII power dynamics, exacerbates tensions. Kofi Annan once noted, "No reform of the UN will be complete without reform of the Security Council." A potential way forward involves increasing representation for emerging economies, fostering dialogue, and prioritizing global cooperation over geopolitical rivalries to achieve a balanced and effective UN system.